Sunday, September 30, 2007

Thinkquote of the day: Mind from matter?

I am told that the German-born American biologist Max Delbruck (1906-1981) began to study neuroscience in his later years, and came to the following conclusion:

We start with the naïve question: How can mind emerge from dead matter as the result of purely physical processes? Mind then looks back on itself and says, “Aha, this is how I came about.” (Like Baron Munchhausen, pulling himself by his hair out of the mud.)

- Referenced in The duality of psycho-physics by
Stanley A. Klein to Delbruck, M. (1986): Mind from Matter? Blackwell Scientific Publishing, Oxford.(1986)

Of course, that makes neuroscience is by definition a dualistic enterprise - it deals with the interface between mind and brain. I don't expect either a materialist or an idealist to be happy with that. Each will be trying to eliminate the part they don't like. Hence eliminative materialism, more popular nowadays than eliminative idealism.


Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home